Why is Israel army so strong, The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) ranks 17th among the most powerful forces in the world. Israel is the only country in the world that used a missile defense system during the war.
MilitaryEzyInfo.com – Walk into the officers’ barracks of the Israel Defense Forces Southern Command (IDF) and you would think that the most powerful army in the Middle East is on the verge of collapse. The commanders eat here in a century-old Ottoman barn.
Why is Israel army so strong, Here are the facts
In the winter, rain drips off the roof onto the old walls, puddles form next to the buffet, and officers can eat the same simple salads and fat schnitzel as the soldiers.” Our troops are not spoiled, “said the reserve brigade. She knows that money is the main objective to keep the troops alert.
But once the battle begins, officers in the aging mess hall could use enormous resources. A battery of Iron Dome missile defense systems, hundreds of snipers, air support by the world’s most advanced drones, F-35 squadrons are state-of-the-art fighter jets.
In an emergency, the entire tank division can be deployed within hours. All these are just a small part of the Israel Defense Forces’ fighting strength, but much more powerful than the entire German Bundeswehr, which has only a third of its fighter jets at flight capability, and the deployment of more than 3,300 soldiers “will soon reach its limits,” said former military and political adviser to Chancellor Angela Merkel Retired General Erich Wad says.
With a standing army of about 170,000 men, the IDF and the Bundeswehr are about the same size, but the German population is 10 times that size.The IDF is active throughout the Middle East and is always ready for battle. There are twice as many fighters and all is well.
How is Israeli Army so Strong?
Israel can immediately mobilize more than 400,000 reservists within a few weeks in an emergency and supply ammunition from its emergency stockpile. The German Bundeswehr can only deploy one combat-ready brigade. According to Wade, the ammunition needed for two days of combat is sufficient. At the same time, Germany’s military budget is about 43.2 billion euros per year, three times the budget of the IDF. How do the Israelis do it? Apples and pears cannot be compared, warns Haddad, who previously served as financial advisor to the Chief of Staff of the Israel Defense Forces and head of the budget department of the Ministry of Defense and now works at the National Security Institute in Tel Aviv: “The largest variable component that affects the fixed costs of the army should be protected The size of the territory.
Germany is 16 times larger than Israel, so the Bundeswehr has to support more infrastructure. The IDF also benefits from conscription, “Professional soldiers are much more expensive than conscripts,” said Haddad. The federal army has to pay 170,000 salaries, but the IDF has only 40,000 professional soldiers. They are often paid less than soldiers in other armies. The rest of the team is made up of conscripts who serve up to three years at a salary of about 250 euros a month.
Conscription gives the IDF an additional advantage. According to Wade, 20,000 jobs remain vacant in the federal military, but IDF military service provides “access to the elite”. It makes it easier to get talented people into positions of responsibility without having to compete with the free market,” Haddad said.
Despite the low salary, recruiters are highly motivated because they can gain responsibility and experience in their future professional life from a young age; 19-year-old boys and girls carry out strategically important projects under their own responsibility, providing a system that can cost millions.
It may seem risky, but it works surprisingly well.” When it comes to the development of new technologies, it’s more effective than any other army in the world,” said Haddad. 70 percent of projects are successful, compared to up to 10 percent of other armies.
“Our Iron Dome missile defense system would cost 10 times as much if developed by the United States,” he said. Unlike other armies, untested weapons systems will soon reach the front line: “The development time will be shortened. Mistakes are mistakes. Nothing is perfect at first, but we know how to handle it well.
In comparison, Wad speaks of the “dramatic densification of regulations” of the federal military. There are “tens of thousands of ways to regulate and regulate”. People who act are always really breaking the rules.” This minimizes initiative and promotes inactivity, which means “the idea of reinsurance is widespread and especially high.
Despite the large budget, “the percentage of investment in Israel’s military budget is much higher than in Germany,” says Wad. From this, it is easy to conclude that “the financial resources of the German Bundeswehr were not and are not alone in Germany”.
Automated performance skills
IDFs haven’t been very effective for a long time; until the 1970s, they swallowed a third of the state budget. For a long time, this state was justified by the motto “Guns instead of stockings”: where the daily struggle for survival takes place, resistance always comes first.
The officers received the highest salaries and retired at age 45. But in the 1990s, this became economically impossible. The government took a lesson in economics. The Army currently receives only about 5.5 percent of the national budget, and police officers today earn more than combatants.
Management consultants have helped the Army undergo severe reforms. The bureaucracy has been drastically reduced and guidelines have been tightened. For example, previously all cars were strictly painted brown. Today, cars can wear any shade of khaki.” The main thing is that the price has to be acceptable,” says Haddad. You can save millions of dollars each year.
But the most important change was to give even small units economic autonomy. In addition, the SDF trains its officers in managerial positions with an emphasis on efficiency.” We created incentives for savings, and part of the savings remains at the full disposal of the unit, “said Haddad. In the German Bundeswehr you can only dream of such a dream.
Here, everything is limited by “a military regime independent of the army, a post-war relic of the Basic Law, financial control to finance the front line,” said Wad.
There is an “inefficient nexus” between combat troops and the logistics apparatus, and an “inefficient nexus” between the “offshore” of military administration.
“There are hundreds of decision-makers in the ministerial bureaucracy and at the highest levels of government, but few in charge.”
However, generals also see the position of the troops as a decisive issue. For Israeli officers, “the army is the center of life. Becoming a soldier is not a job, but a calling to ensure the survival of one’s family,” Haddad said. Staff motivation is high, which helps cut costs and stay competitive.
The federal military, on the other hand, is characterized by “a lot of bureaucracy and reinsurance and a formal career mentality,” Wad said.
This is true more than anything else “in the defense ministry, procurement departments and too many senior officials, headquarters and command levels. There are too many chiefs with no clear responsibilities and too few “Indians”.
“To change this, it is important to create and strengthen the link between the military and society, as in Israel, and to support the idea that everyone is trying to protect themselves.” It’s time for a “general social consensus” to define “what we need federal troops for, what we need federal troops for, and who we should be fighting against if necessary.
So the most important lesson for him is that Germany needs to learn from the IDF, and above all, it needs more will and public support to make the Bundeswehr combat-ready.